On 2010-02-20 Jonathan Strawn, Albuquerque, NM wrote: This is a book about dreams, ideas and high concepts. Too bad it´s not about story and characters.
The premise is a great one, and along with the absolutly fantastic cover art it hooked me on the book instantly: 10 years after it vanished from orbit, the Space Shuttle Venture returns to Earth in a firey crash. All but 1 of the crew are missing, the ship is covered in strange material, and it shows signs of having landed on Mars.
Done. I´m there.
Except that´s about it. The rest of the story is a gathering of scientists who all had their dreams crushed when the manned space program was cancelled after the disapperance of the shuttle 10 years prior. They interview the remaining crew member, disect the strange technology of the shuttle, and try to piece together where it was for the past 10 years.
Most of the book plays out like a NASA CSI episode, with crew members finding strange readings, relating it to theoretical physics, and then finding some other strange reading.
There are some early signs of conflict with the military, but the scientists just brush them aside when the plot requires it. Most of the second half is narrated exposition, explanining where the shuttle went & how, and then the book ends with a moment that is supposed to be inspiring, but plays out poorly as it felt rushed and inconsequential.
The art is great when it is depicting decrepit buildings, outer space vistas and odd technology. Not so much with the people. The characters have expressions that are exaggerated almost to the point of cartoonish proportions. Dave Stewart´s colors are really the star of the book, bringing a life to the art that is stunning in every scene.
There are so many great ideas, and great moments in this book, I just wish it was better. But in the end it really plays out like a kind of ´thinking out loud´ about space exploration. . And summed up by saying Grand Dreams, Little Story. Currently Orbiter has an overall rating of 8 over 10.
Orbiter can also be found in the following searches:
Vertigo claimed In this science fiction mystery tale, Venture, a space shuttle that disappeared ten years ago with its crew of seven, miraculously returns from outer space without warning or explanation. Occupied by only an insane pilot, the spacecraft shows evidence of a remarkable journey through the solar systems. Now, in order to solve the mystery of the shuttle´s inexplicable journey and the fate of its six lost astronauts, three NASA specialists are called upon to investigate the alien instrumentation and materials that adorn Venture. But as secrets are revealed, it soon becomes apparent that the shuttle´s journey not only took it outside our solar system but to a realm of existence that is unimaginable. Suggested for Mature Readers.
Item that are similar to Orbiter can be found at: